Compressibility definition ? >> Blogging >> Forum
wr-forum WOW mod

SearchSearch   Users   Registration   Entrance
Today: 23.07.2025 - 00:37:56
Pages:  1  

Compressibility definition ?

Advertising

.
AuthorMessage

AvusBluR

user




Statistics:
Messages: 2,255
Registration: 05.23.2002

How is defined compressibility of a movie ? I read about it many times, having rough idea what it is, but in spite of many searches have never found its definition. BTW I cannot force forum to search by AND logic.(now, worked before I think) Even "+A +B" and "A AND B" gives results "ORed" according to result page.

---------------------
Message # 1 11.02.25 - 00:45:12
RE: Compressibility definition ?

jhfutch

user




Statistics:
Messages: 63
Registration: 04.06.2003

Well I guess one definition would be the size per a given quant. So a compressible movie will have a smaller size per quant, giving you a lower average quant for a set size. A movie that is hard to compress will be larget per quant and as such require a large size/bitrate to hit the same average quant as the compressable movie.

---------------------
1985 635 CSi Euro - For Sale
Message # 2 11.02.25 - 00:55:47
RE: Compressibility definition ?

POPS RACER

user




Statistics:
Messages: 128
Registration: 07.17.2003

Exactly what I meant. Too many higher/lower, smaller/larger's in one paragraph.

---------------------
Dinan CAI and Software,TC Kline Suspension - OE Sports, x-brace,SuperSprint Exhaust,AC Schnitzer Strut Bar/Pedals/roof spoiler,BBS CH
Message # 3 11.02.25 - 01:04:32
RE: Compressibility definition ?

Vdbcrlp001

user




Statistics:
Messages: 934
Registration: 09.23.2003

I understand quite well, what compressibility is about. But it should be independent on file size, so does liquid density measuring is independent on volume of measuring bottle. What e.g. means compressibility is 60 % ? It should be dependent on movie properties only ( by strict given test procedure) and independent on testing subject ( = me and what I am going to do with a clip ).

---------------------
Message # 4 11.02.25 - 01:11:50
RE: Compressibility definition ?

MCoupeMike

user




Statistics:
Messages: 424
Registration: 12.17.2002

I don`t think there is a strict definition of compressibility. There are too much parameters involved. It depends not only on the source, but on the format (MPEG2, MPEG4 ASP or AVC or something completely different for example wavelet based formats like snow or dirac), the used encoder and its algorithms and the used settings.

---------------------
MCoupeMike - AIM: MCoupeMike2K - 368S/8 '00 Blown M Coupe '00 323Ci '98 Z3 2.8
Message # 5 11.02.25 - 01:18:38
RE: Compressibility definition ?

drivingmachine

user




Statistics:
Messages: 133
Registration: 11.30.2002

CompCheck vs Average Bitrate 

---------------------
Message # 6 11.02.25 - 01:26:23
RE: Compressibility definition ?

fluffy_boulder

user




Statistics:
Messages: 4
Registration: 04.12.2002

Don't know about your guys but I still have my doubts about the reliability of the Compcheck, after all it only checks portions of the source with real fast scenes changes, in not like an full analysis as on some transcorders like Shrink which checks the whole source before transcoding to the desired size/quality. Right now I'm kind of leaning to-wards the idea of finding the average bitrate of the source and give a percentage of that rate to the encoder to work on. Since I'm a 1-Pass encode freak(don't care much about a target size), I been trying different methods lately like fixed Q-Based encodes and fixed bitrate encodes with an 20% of the average bitrate from the source which is calculated by using ReMPEG2 on a single VOB file, and so far the results are very good but I still have to tweak some XVID settings to see which one gives the best results.

---------------------
i have twenties on my powerwheels
Message # 7 11.02.25 - 01:36:49
RE: Compressibility definition ?

TranceMaster

user




Statistics:
Messages: 3
Registration: 02.18.2002

Edit: Reply to Kopernikus In fact, I do not need it, neither others do. I just like things are called by their proper names and not to like the opposite. There is many ways how to measure compresibility. It is just about agreement/consensus which is used when people talk about that. And it is not rocket science. I have not written anything about 2 full Encodings at all. I fact if I do some tests I use Code:

---------------------
-- mike
Message # 8 11.02.25 - 01:45:27
RE: Compressibility definition ?
Engaging Record from MID editor : Previous topicNext topic: I'm new at this
Pages:  1  

The administrator has prohibited guests from replying to messages! To register, follow the link: register


Participants